Build Your Charm Story

Build Your Charm Story

Jewelry that reflects your personality, your travels, your memories.

Shop Charms
Design Something Totally You

Design Something Totally You

Create a custom charm made just for you.

Create Your Charm
Wear What Matters

Wear What Matters

From playful icons to meaningful symbols, find your vibe.

Explore Collection
  • Unique & Playful Charm Designs
  • Design Your Own Custom Piece
  • Express Your Personality
  • Travel & Symbol Inspired Charms
  • Meaningful Gift Ideas
  • Quality Craftsmanship
  • Mix, Match & Build Your Collection
  • Unique & Playful Charm Designs
  • Design Your Own Custom Piece
  • Express Your Personality
  • Travel & Symbol Inspired Charms
  • Meaningful Gift Ideas
  • Quality Craftsmanship
  • Mix, Match & Build Your Collection

Shop Your Style
View all

Featured Pieces

Design Your Own Charm

Looking for something truly one of a kind? Share your idea with us and we will help bring it to life. Whether it is a personal symbol, a meaningful memory, or something completely unique, we are here to create it with you.

Start Designing

More Than Just Jewelry

Charmed I’m Sure was created with a simple idea. Jewelry should tell a story. Each charm represents a moment, a memory, or a piece of your personality.

We believe in self expression through thoughtful design. Whether you are building your own collection or gifting someone special, every piece carries meaning.

Learn More

Why Choose Charmed I’m Sure?

Unique Designs

Original pieces inspired by creativity and personality with inspirations from all over the world.

Express Yourself

Build combinations that reflect your interests and experiences and shop from an ever growing assortment of charms and accessories.

Custom Options

Create something designed entirely around your vision and something that can treasured for years to come.

Quality Craftsmanship

Made with care and attention to detail. We make everything by hand here in New York City using recycled metals and high quality stones. By supporting us, you are supporting a small business and a number of makers and designers here in the Big Apple.

Start Building Your Collection Today

Layer, mix, match, and express who you are through every piece you wear.

Explore All Charms